Finally a REALLY good pizza place on DD!!!! The manicotti was such a treat!! This cheeseaholic was a happy camper! And the salad was fresh & crisp & so much more than the lettuce & croutons usually rcvd! Can't wait to try the pizza. Thank u Jimmy's NY Pizzeria.
K
Kelly G
Local Expert • 30 contributions
Loved
• 1/31/25
• DoorDash order
The Calzone was cooked perfectly. It had lots of delicious garlic on top! The Manicotti was also good, with marinara sauce that was well balanced and came with a garlic knot. I will definitely be ordering from Jimmy's again. A nice change from the larger pizza places.
L
Lynzi T
18 contributions
Loved
• 1/6/24
• DoorDash order
Jimmys is one of our FAVORITE pizza places and we were so excited to see it on here for delivery! Pizza is excellent as always has a nice flop to it, full of flavor and the crust is done perfectly. The Stromboli is full of meat and cheese and is exploding with flavor.
C
Cassandra F
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
Loved
• 5/18/25
• DoorDash order
their pizza is amazing. I love their sauce. I read some other reviews, and I believe those who have said their food is salty are the type of people that like bland food. the food was seasoned to perfection.
I had a Keto Bowl and it was Jam-packed with sauce, meats, cheese and olives. My husband had a Stromboli that was massive. it was fresh, and topped with garlic. I've eaten here 3 times in one week and they have not failed me once.
M
Michael J
5 contributions
Liked
• 7/2/25
• DoorDash order
When I think of classic NY pizza, this pizza is what I think of. Good sauce, crust is a perfect mix of crisp with a bit of chew. Doesn't flop too much when you fold it. Cheese is great, doesn't slide off. Great pizza, especially for the price.