BEST NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA IN COLORADO SPRINGS! For those new to New York style pizza, here are the facts. This type of pizza features hand-tossed dough, thinly spread pie-like crust cut into wider tha…
The crust at Joey's is exactly how we love a New York style crust to be! The toppings are fresh, and the sauce has a perfect herby flavor, without being too much.
This is a go to spot for us to order from!
And the cheese in the Mozzarella Sticks is amazing! Real cheese that pulls apart perfectly
P
Pamela D
8 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/11/25
• DoorDash order
All of the food we ordered was over cooked. I ordered extra cheese pizza and half pepperoni and the cheese was very sparse and we got 5 slice of pepperoni and 3 just cheese which isn't half.NY Hand Tossed Pizza (14") Mozzarella Sticks
N
Nicki V
13 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/30/23
• DoorDash order
bottom of pizza was burnt. Ordered a half and half. Got I kid you not, one piece of cheese and the rest of the pizza was everything else.
Tiramisu was a tiny child size dessert for the price. Not impressed
F
Frank M
4 contributions
Loved
• 11/22/25
• DoorDash order
I AM from NY; more specifically, Brooklyn; even more specifically, Bensonhurst. I am Italian; more specifically, Sicilian! So, when a Sicilian from Bensonhurst tells you that Joey’s makes the BEST (if not only) authentic NY round hand tossed pizza in Colorado Springs, believe it! Other’s that claim “NY style pizza?” Fuggetabotem! Joeys is the real deal! Period.
B
Brian S
Local Expert • 41 contributions
Loved
• 5/17/24
• DoorDash order
Pretty much perfect! The NY Hand Tossed Pizza (18") with pepperoni was exactly what I needed for my Friday lunch. And a few meals after. Delivery was really fast too.
