For those new to New York style pizza, here are the facts. This type of pizza features hand-tossed dough, thinly spread pie-like crust cut into wider than regular slices. A hint of this, and a dash of…
I absolutely love this place. I really enjoy creating my own 14'' NY Hand Tossed and doing pepperoni, garlic, extra cheese. The Calzone is the best Calzone I've had and I was raised in NJ.
N
Nancy J
79 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/30/26
• DoorDash order
I was was really looking forward to this because it seems like recent reviews are bad but old reviews are good. The Margherita Pizza was overcooked, with burnt bubbled cheese, and the Fried Mushrooms - New! were undercooked, with soft spots in the breading and I had to throw them in the air fryer. Big portion of the musrooms, though. There must not be someone who checks the quality of the food before it goes out.
A
Alice R
Local Expert • 44 contributions
Loved
• 9/24/21
• DoorDash review
One thing I don't live about having moved to Alaska is that there NO place that makes pizza even remotely as good as Joey's. Sad, but devastatingly true. I made a quick trip back for three days and am ordering two of my favorites to pack in my luggage for home! (2 gluten-free with sausage, basil, ricotta, roasted red pepper)
P
Patrina S
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/28/25
• DoorDash order
Zeppole's were hard and there was not ten in bag. There was no white sugar on them and no chocolate drizzle on side I wouldn't order again
Q
Quaid F
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/26/25
• DoorDash order
I have ordered this pizza many times and it has never been this small or prepared like this. Total false advertising with still saying it joeys and saying I'll be getting the same thing on the app but getting a completely different thing delivered.