I LOVEEEEE THIS PLACE! It is always my go to (unless someone in the office forces me to go somewhere else) it is always so flavorful. The portion size is great for the price. I don't think I've ever had a bad meal from them. Everything always looks fresh and made to order. Hands down the best place in Middletown. Wish they came out to my home town!
K
Kat W
Local Expert • 34 contributions
Liked
• 10/29/26
• DoorDash order
The pizza came cold which is disappointing but expected. I feel like the crust is too oily, never crispy unless you actually eat there. The slices are big and the price is fair. I wouldn't order delivery again but when I'm out I always stop there because the food is really good when made fresh and the service is great too.
H
Heidi K
Local Expert • 89 contributions
Loved
• 8/29/26
• DoorDash order
as always the team at Joey's pizza made flavorful tasty food. we got a Margherita pizza this time to try and the flavor was great. the Cheesesteak pizza was really tasty as well. the Fried Mushrooms as always are perfect. you can taste the freshness of all the ingredients and the portion size is perfect for sharing. even my fur baby's loves Joey's pizza today they got a slice of Margherita pizza just because they don't get many special treats. my oldest dog licked his lips and was visibly upset when we told him only one slice. what ever you order from Joey's pizza be it an appetizer, lunch or dinner you can't go wrong.
H
Heidi K
Local Expert • 89 contributions
Loved
• 7/23/25
• DoorDash order
stuffed sheels*Stuffed Shells (3) are so good portion size is perect, and will forsure order again. the Garlic Knots (6) are melt in your mouth perfection agoid match for the stuffed shells. iwould sudjest a little sugar to the sauce but perfection.
H
Heidi K
Local Expert • 89 contributions
Loved
• 7/11/26
• DoorDash order
Shrimp Basket With Fries was perfect and they sub onion rings out for me just kike I had asked because they have the best onion rings in town and hit my craving perfect. Fried Mushrooms absolutely delicious as always. Joey's pizza is my main squeeze when it comes to hitting my cravings for anything that I may crave, and they do it with such care, and judgment free. I can't wait for my friends to come up from KY and taste the great food