The TONY SUPREMO on gluten free base was incredibly overcooked, the base was so burnt you wonder how they let that go out to a customer.
Meanwhile, somehow all 3 pizzas we ordered were cold, like not warm, but the toppings were all cold as if they'd been sitting out.
To top off this relatively poor experience, we also ordered the Vodka Mac & Cheese, and the Macaroni was so overcooked it was basically mush.
The pizza toppings tasted great, the pizza dough was flavourful, but the temperature and lack of care for doneness really ruined our first experience ordering from Johnny Gio's.
Disappointing.
R
Rebecca H
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/3/26
• DoorDash review
Pizza had very little toppings on the whole thing - very little chicken etc. Also Half empty side of sauce upon arrival.
J
Julian E
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/12/25
• DoorDash order
Nasty nasty food overall. Bland, uncooked pizza base with almost raw toppings and an overly tomatoe paste flavoured sauce. Truly terrible for the price. I would never order here again.
