In late spring, Jeff went to New York City, where he learned with some of the world's top pizza chefs at the prestigious Goodfellas' Pizza School.
In late June, Jeff hired Jill Visger as the team's ge…
Consistently excellent pizza. Baked evenly and the toppings are prepared perfectly to complement the pizza. My fave pizza place around Barrington.
K
Katie B
2 contributions
Liked
• 3/20/26
• DoorDash order
Wow.Finally some good pizza!!! The Cavatappi Mushroom & Sausage Via is incredible, perfectly cooked, savory, delightful.
Thr20" Italian Pork and 20" New Yorker were so unique and perfect!
The Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice was better than any cake I have had in years. hands down perfect- is that Swiss buttercream!? 10/10 perfect.
J
Jennifer T
Local Expert • 70 contributions
Loved
• 10/13/22
• DoorDash order
Everything here always exceeds expectations. Super fresh, high quality ingredients and my order is always correct. Best pizza around, hands down. The salads are amazing too. And this family owned business is active and generous within our community. Skip the big chains - the food here is better and so is the service!
R
Rose L
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/5/23
• DoorDash review
Ratings were great, regretted it! I gave it a try. Ordered 3 pizzas, Margherita, Cheese and Sausage all New York style. I didn't know New Yorkers ate wheat crust? Barely any cheese on the cheese pizza or any one of them. Margherita didn't have actual tomatoes, had spoonfuls of tomato sauce to look like one, wait it gets better, Sausage barely there with green pepper and onion. 3 pieces on the whole pizza! Each one a 12" pizza for $16 bucks+ delivered cold, I must be crazy! Penne with oil, garlic and artichokes (they didn't have broccoli), overcooked and dry. Garlic knots drenched in butter and leaked in bags. Cannoli's were slopped together. In the garbage it went. Total cost $80+. I usually don't write these reviews because they are never taken seriously. Don't waste your time with this place. They need to shut the doors until they can improve their quality and service!
N
Nick D
3 contributions
Loved
• 5/23/26
• DoorDash order
The NY gluten friendly is the best I've ever had, and the quality is consistently very good with everything we've ordered-we've never had something here we haven't liked. Our favorite pizza place for life!
