2/4 cookies I got weren't what I ordered but they were still good!
P
Pamela P
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/27/26
• DoorDash order
I got the oatmeal scotchy, Oreo, explosion, macadamia nut, and brookie. The first two were in a tightly sealed bag and stale. They were obviously made another day. There was not a hint of butterscotch in the oatmeal cookie. My son liked the Oreo cookie. The nut cookie was fresh with a resealable seal, though it had an off putting heavy lemon flavor, even though lemon was not listed as an ingredient. I don't like their cookies and would not order again. I had them a couple years ago and thought the quality was not good. When I order a $5 cookie from a cookie store, I expect it to be made the same day and be full of flavor.
P
Pamela P
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/22/24
• DoorDash order
"Clean" Ingredients But Not Delicious Cookies. Middle-aged mom found cookies not very flavorful but made with clean ingredients. College-age son rated them 6 of 10 for flavor. We had S'more, Brookie, Scotchy, Triple Choc. and Oreo Explosion. We much prefer another cookie vendor on Eastside of Milwaukee that's open to wee hours of morning.
