The Egg Salad is perfect.the grilled sourdough with the egg salad bomb. The Brownie Bliss Amazing my all time favorite. Even With it being a delivery Leatherby's make sure its the same quality as if your eat in.
S
Sheridan A
1 contributions
Loved
• 5/2/26
• DoorDash order
Been to this place before and love the food! today was my birthday and as a pregnant woman wanting something good for her birthday this was amazing!
Western Tri Tip was perfect with their house fries 10/10 never really had their Shirley Temple - but it was really good! portions are big enough to have leftovers after!
B
Brooke S
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/22/24
• DoorDash order
Steak Sandwich was awful. It was more like sliced roast beef vs steak - also was $18 absolute rip off there was also about one slice of the meat? Ice cream was great of course. But would not recommend the food. Very disappointing!
G
Gretchen B
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
Liked
• 4/1/26
• DoorDash order
Triple Cheddar Sandwich is great, but I order it with No Side. There are 2 sides offered which do not cost extra-fries and potato salad. The fries are definitely sub-par and most traditional potato salads have pickles or pickle relish - both of which are are show stoppers for me. Since the menu doesn't say, I will not take the chance. Also most potato salads smother everything with too much mayo. Again, I won't take the chance.
The Build Your Own Ice Cream is more of a menu issue. I have ordered this same menu with both GrubHub and DoorDash. The DoorDash works out to be cheaper by several dollars, but the selections are fewer. The one selection that is missing is whipped cream or no whipped cream. You must accept whipped cream and by default, the merichino cherry. There is no way to even leave a note to not put it on. Thought I could just remove it, but then I remove some of the ice cream because of the packaging. I will still order it, but am disappointed that you can call it a choice when it is required.
N
Naomi V
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/5/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered a Create Your Own 3- online. Wouldn't give an option to order extra or double of a sauce so if you want the same sauce twice you can't choose it.
You will only get 2 servings of sauce instead. So I called the store to request my 3rd sauce
Be a double of something I ordered plus the 2nd single sauce serving. I specified multiple times to ensure I would avoid getting all one sauce. When Ireceived my order it was all one sauce (marshmallow) & it was smothered. Not only that, I ordered the white cake & it was a small cube of cake that was less than a third of the entire ice cream plate. Spent $23 on marshmallow sauce, vanilla ice cream, & a sugar cube sized portion of cake.
