AMAZING As Usual! Lillo's is GENUINELY the BEST 16 oz Cheesesteak in the area!!! & there are A LOT of other really good spots within ~15-20 min radius of Lillo's. So that says A LOT!
I Love the Longhots peppers-ALWAYS on the side- they complement the steak so well BUT**Their Heat Level Varies from pepper to pepper A LOT so BE MINDFUL!!!
The menu is small, which is always a good sign. Almost ALWAYS means they've PERFECTED evey single item! Everything i've tried is OUTSTANDING,portions are HUGE, high quality FRESH ingredients, Seasoned to perfection. The staff & service are AMAZING, & Price$ is Fair within the $16-$20 average!
I really have ZERO NEGATIVES to say about this place. They're 1000% Worth the Hype, I PROMISE you will NOT be disappointed!!!!
J
Jessica C
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
Loved
• 5/7/25
• DoorDash order
The Meatballs - HUGE & Delicious, the Liscio Seeded Roll as always Fresh & Amazing, & OF COURSE** 16 oz Cheesesteak is ALWAYS the *STAR* of the show & she did not disappoint today! TONS of meat, with so much melted cooper sharp cheese and MIYM fried onions all perfectly spread evenly throughout the sandwich all on a fresh soft roll- IT DOESN'T GET BETTER THAN THIS!
My only critique would be to roast the Longhots longer. They were still pretty raw and tough to peel in some spots, and just getting soft in others but lacked the signature black "roasted" skin.
J
Jackie L
2 contributions
Liked
• 3/12/26
• DoorDash order
Love how much comes on the Meat Lovers pizza worth the price tag.
The White Pie taste fresh and probably the best white pizza I've had since moving to NJ. Would also work well with some grilled chicken on top if you wanted a protein but its great as it is.
A
Amie T
Local Expert • 48 contributions
Loved
• 7/17/24
• DoorDash order
I heard this was the best 16 oz Cheesesteak ever, and I was not disappointed. Delicious. Overflowing with meat. Tons of cooper sharp cheese, and it was chopped and mixed in. I split the steak with 2 people and could still barely eat any pizza. The Tomato Pie Plain was good, though you should know there's cheese on it. The Mustard Pie Plain was interesting. We got it with the sausage as recommended. I enjoyed it but was overfull from the steak so I only had half a slice. I will be dreaming of this cheesesteak for weeks.
E
Erika H
3 contributions
Loved
• 3/18/26
• DoorDash order
We love Lillo's! The rolls are always so fresh, there are huge portions of meat on the rolls and everything is always so tasty! This time we ordered the buffalo chicken cheesesteak and it was amazing! We could split that between two adults with no issue.
The only qualm I have is with the DoorDash platform and being unable to find french fries anywhere to order despite knowing they have them on the menu. 10/10 will definitely be ordering again. Already a repeat customer who is lucky enough to live just a few miles away from the Hainesoort location!
