https://a816-health.nyc.gov/ABCEatsRestaurants/#!/Search
With the launch of Ma Smith's Dessert Café, a branch of MAKE MY CAKE, Make My Cake continues to leave its mark on the baking industry.
Custo…
Delivery was fast. Cheesecakes slices were good portions, fresh and delicious! Second time ordering and very pleased.
S
Shakeema P
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/30/26
• DoorDash order
Probably the worst banana pudding I've ever had. The wafers and bananas were almost non existent. The container I ate tasted like a container of banana flavored box pudding with about 5 wafers and maybe 4 slices of banana.
Consistency is key. I will never order again.
L
Latoya T
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/19/25
• DoorDash order
The last 2x the cake was dry. Called to confirm it wasnt dry today. No apology or replacement slice offered. They were Out of stock of Red Velvet Cheese Cake, substituted sweet potato instead which would've been fine but it was completely broken apart and messy. I gave them a chance to make it right by calling rather than leave a bad review, but they fumbled the ball again. Food is 7.5/10 but customer satisfaction/business practices could use work. Adding an extra goodie and providing a presentable dessert would've gone far. Hopefully, this review helps for the future.
S
Sarah W
10 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/2/23
• DoorDash order
We were pretty disappointed by our order. The Lemon Cupcake is just a butter cupcake with plain buttercream frosting and a dollop of lemon jelly on top. I was hoping for something with a strong lemon flavor, a nice mix of tart and sweet --- at the very least, lemon cake and lemon frosting, but all we got was an overly sweet plain cupcake dressed up to look like lemon. It wasn't good.
All of the cakes were too dense and dry, both cupcakes and the German chocolate slice.
German chocolate cake is my favorite, and I was so excited to try this. It was so disappointing. The cake was dry and the coconut pecan frosting was overpowered by the heavy chocolate frosting on the sides. It was also way too sweet. The German Chocolate Slice was just not good.
The Velvet Gold (CHOCOLATE VELVET CUPCAKE) looked like it had been wrapped in plastic before it came to us. The "cheesecake" topping tasted and looked like it had been sitting around for a while.
The menu items looked good in the photos, but everything ended up being dry, dense, and way too sweet. Given that we tried 3 items, it isn't just a case of not liking one thing -- unfortunately, we just cannot recommend this place.
V
Vera K
Local Expert • 71 contributions
Loved
• 10/27/23
• DoorDash order
Sweet Potato and Peach Cobbler are both good. They are premade and felt very cold to the touch. Very generous sizing, each pie could feel at least 2 people. Same with the cobbler.
