Food plays an important role in a city's cultural life. Try some of the best pizzas in town to get a sense of what New Windsor has to offer. Mamma Mia! Cafe & Pizzeria has quickly become one of New Wi…
This is the best Pizza I have had in Newburgh New York in 20 years. I have found a new place. To feed my family. It has great flavor and the crust is amazingly thin and crisp and not falling apart.Closest thing i've gotten to Bronx pizza in quite a while other than in the Bronx. please don't change anything.
G
Gary G
10 contributions
Liked
• 2/18/26
• DoorDash order
Omg best biggest chicken parmigiana dinner I ever had as had it over 3 times already with pasta and salad so so good
G
Gary G
10 contributions
Loved
• 12/3/25
• DoorDash order
Omg chicken Marsala was so good and no matter what I order it is phenomenal as I usually order 2x per week EVERYTHING is sooooo good my best place to order best place around staff is so friendly definitely keep ordering from
M
Marilyn E
Local Expert • 25 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/3/24
• DoorDash order
I was craving an Eggplant Parm Hero and was sorely disappointed. There was only about a tablespoon of sauce on it. Needless to say it was very dry and could not eat much of it at all. Can't believe they would make a sandwich with barely any sauce on it. Would not recommend this restaurant and will not be ordering from here again.
A
Andrea P
Emerging Expert • 41 contributions
Loved
• 4/12/25
• DoorDash order
Everything was delicious! Best pizza in the area. I never feel guilty eating from here. Nothing is greasy or soggy. I ordered 2 nights in a row! I had some restrictions and they were so accommodating. My new go to place! Love good food and good customer service!