Hands down the best meal we've had in awhile. Oxtail was full of rich, umami flavor and absolutely melted in the mouth. Cornbread was sweet and perfectly baked, and the sweet corn was off the cob just how the wife likes it. The beef pastellilo was perfectly seasoned and full of flavor, different from your typical jamaican beef patty in the very good way.
We will absolutely be ordering again!
B
Brittany A
11 contributions
Loved
• 7/27/25
• DoorDash review
Everything I've ever ordered has always been amazing! The freshness of everything is great! The fried chicken, the rice balls down to the hush puppies absolutely mouth watering. Large portion sizes enough for left overs! I would absolutely order again!
D
Deidre B
1 contributions
Loved
• 12/8/24
• DoorDash order
The curry chicken was excellent! The chicken was very tender- falling off the bone. Greens and yams delicious! Amount of food is awesome for the price. I highly recommend!
K
KATHY S
44 contributions
Loved
• 1/25/25
• DoorDash order
outstanding fare!! Absolutely delicious! The haddock perfect size and coating nicely seasoned and CRISPY!! THE COLE SLAW is delightfully unique; unexpected variety of vegs, perfect dressing! The best hush puppies I've ever had!And the yams to die for! My selections made the perfect medley for my tastes and it is very evident that any and all the offerings completely from Marshall's stand above and out side the box of commercial canned humdrum!! Excellent+ quality, delicious on the palate, VERY reasonable prices, pride in prepped and topped with excellent service of DoorDash!!! 10 stars all around! (the only negative is "not from scatch" tartar sauce). Will be returning in future to Marshall's for awesomeness!! THANK YOU!!
G
Gian T
2 contributions
Loved
• 3/26/26
• DoorDash order
I get the Shrimp RASTA PASTA everytime when it's on their menu. It tastes amazing and it always gets to me steaming hot. The portion fills me up and I usually have leftovers.
The mild wings were amazing, but they gave me more of a boss sauce taste rather than mild, but for me it was amazing because I'm a Rochester native and boss sauce is so good.
I recommend this place to anyone and it's honestly hands down the best food in Elmira.