Had the The Godfather, the The Real Italian - Vegetarian & a Large Vanilla Ricotta Cannoli , genuinely impressed by & thorougjly enjoyed all of them. it is rare that sandwich shops actually give you a big sando & fill it with lots of goodies but Matteo definitely delivered! Flavour profile is well conceived, much more worth the price than most places, variegate choices, fresh, not covered in plastic, I do recommend!
S
Sue-anne L
Local Expert • 49 contributions
Liked
• 10/21/26
• DoorDash order
Firstly, I will start with the negatives.
The so called Gourmet Pie was sadly awful, not at all flavoursome in fact really basic and that's being kind. It was deposited into the bin.
The Sausage Roll was not too bad but both of these items were so overpriced I am gobsmacked that each of them cost $11.
I cannot rate this place negatively due to these brought in pastries from another business but I do not recommend at all.
However, my order of The Undertaker, upon reading the positive reviews of people who have had a great experience here prompted me to give it a shot.
Well, hello! I have never ordered a roll from anywhere that offers such great quality ingredients piled high and actually screams care and value for your dollar because we are not talking about the cheapest of ingredients here, we are talking about fair dinkum deli style standards that will impress you.
I know I was amazed but please, please, do not lower the standards by offering produce that doesn't hold a candle to the quality that you guys can produce.
Initially I was going to leave a less than positive review because of the price yet what I received with regards to the roll made in house I now understand, it was pretty bloody good!!!!!
R
Rhiannon P
1 contributions
Loved
• 8/15/26
• DoorDash review
Ohhhh my, that was actually the best sandwich I've ever had. So much so I needed to come here and leave a review!
M
Mikayla D
2 contributions
Loved
• 1/29/26
• DoorDash order
Photo doesn't do this sandwich justice! Stacked with delicious deli meat and fresh salads, both filling and so tasty ! Definitely will be ordering again ! 10/10 !
J
Jade H
1 contributions
Loved
• 9/18/24
• DoorDash order
The Matteo's Original can confirm say one of the best sand I've ever had, the Sausage Roll From Wonder Pies my dad liked and hes a picky man so this is a 10/10 from us
