Very good pizza the mushrooms were different than most places they were cooked to perfection. Hard to explain but they had an earthy and juicy taste. The wings were crispy and the meat was tender. Definitely worth trying!
S
Summer V
5 contributions
Loved
• 4/18/26
• DoorDash order
Mattys has the absolute best pizza in the Batavia area. the sizes are the same as other places but prices are less!!! Always Fresh out of the oven, Not Cheap on toppings like their competitors! Mattys is our new pizza place!
M
Michael P
11 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/17/24
• DoorDash order
Pizza was great. Wings were nasty. As soon as I opened the carton I could see the ends of the wings were extremely over cooked. At $1.40 each for small/medium sized wings without carrots or celery and at least some napkins...I'd expect them to be perfect. If you're looking for good pizza and wings, look elsewhere for the wings; I am.
M
Michael R
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/10/23
• DoorDash order
The portion size for the Stuffed Jalapenos doesn't justify the 12 dollar price tag. you only get 5 small peppers. I figured for 12 bucks. I woulda gotten more for my money's worth. their good. I just don't feel the price matches the portion size. the Country Sweet Pizza is good .. it's just always undercooked every time I get pizza here . if they just leave it in the oven a Lil longer . the pizza would be rly good. and the Blue Cheese Side is ofc amazing
A
Alexander B
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Liked
• 6/24/22
• DoorDash order
Every pizza I've gotten so far has been great. I've only been getting the 10" personal pizza size so that may be the cause of it. Their stuffed jalapeños are good if not a lil messy, and their garlic bread (both versions) are really good, just a lil too heavy on the herbs/salt sometimes I think.
