Wow, big difference from the baked potato. I got just a few days ago. First one was absolutely huge, and extremely good. The one I received tonight extremely smaller although still tasted good. Why such a difference? Carrot cake amazing again. Will definitely order again, have had some pretty good food from McAllister's. Just a little concerned in regards to the difference in the portion amount.
L
Linda G
Local Expert • 148 contributions
Liked
• 9/15/26
• DoorDash review
Loaded potato was really really good, carrot cake is excellent. The only thing is regarding portion size, had ordered the potato with chicken, melted cheese, and sour cream a few days ago, portion size was enough to feed me for two days. Ordered it again tonight, barely enough for one person. Why such a big difference? For the price paid potato should've been quite a bit bigger. Although still very tasty, very disappointed in portion size.  one picture shows the huge potato I received. The other picture shows the much smaller potato I received.
C
Colin B
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/6/26
• DoorDash order
Veggie chili portion was a joke, i counted about 12 beans, the rest was mediocre chili broth with a fake smoke flavor
L
Linda G
Local Expert • 148 contributions
Liked
• 6 days ago
• DoorDash order
Always a great baked potato, large enough I get at least two dinners! Have ordered several times and not been disappointed.
T
Tammie G
Local Expert • 44 contributions
Liked
• 7/17/23
• DoorDash order
I was expecting shredded beef on the potato, but was pleasantly surprised to see three huge slices! The Colossal Carrot Cake was not as big as years past, but still the same great taste.
