The Memphian is a great choice for anyone looking to switch sandwich food places; originally i had this for the first time while my highschool got catering during our marching band events. It was -- and still is -- the best sandwich ive ever had. This location of McAlisters also never lets me down in term of flavor. Personally, i love mine without the spicy brown mustard. I dont think i could get this any place else.
Super good warm, or cold! So even if you have leftovers, it tastes great and is quite filling too.
Definitely worth a shot. By far my favorite sandwich from this place.
D
Dana W
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
Loved
• 6/6/25
• DoorDash order
1st, I love how McAlister's packages their orders. Everything was tied up neatly and so that nothing leaked or was squished. My cucumber and tomato salad was perfect. Itwas delicately seasoned and had the
perfect balance of flavors. The fruit was sweet and fresh. The chicken salad was creamy and firm - not mushy. My tea lemonade was also peffect most places get it wrong but half tea/half lemonade is perfectly blended.
E
Elizabeth G
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/12/25
• DoorDash order
Spent $30 on a McAlister's Club Wrap, Country Potato Soup, and Mac & Cheese... the McAlister's Club Wrap was so loose and unfilled. The only thing I asked them not to add was tomato, and there was more sauce/lettuce than there was meat (looked nothing like in person or photo). Soup was bland and the same size as the Mac and Cheese side... that being said, it was okay, just not worth the money.
M
Mia M
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/8/25
• DoorDash order
Disappointed with my order
I ordered the Chicken Caesar Wrap from McAlister’s and was really disappointed. There was no chicken at all in the wrap, and the lettuce tasted old and wilted. For the price, I expected something fresh and accurate. I usually enjoy McAlister’s, but this experience was really frustrating hoping quality control improves.
A
Ann M
13 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/19/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered the 1/2 sandwich meal w/baked potato ,but the sandwich wasn't good!! Not enough chicken salad & the bread was BURNT!!!! I've eaten at McAlisters & didn't have any issues....but this time it was Lousy!!!
The potato was good!!
