I love McAlister's, I probably have it at least once a week, and I always get the same things cuz I just love them! Their Chicken & Dumplings is my favorite!! I do wish the bowl was bigger, but i appreciate that there is a bowl or cup option. But the soup is so perfect!! They are also my go to place, or should I say my go to to order from place lol! I used to love getting their Brookie and Brownie bites but they haven't had them in while, at least when I'm ordering so I just get the Brookie which is fabulous. I love everything there! My only issue is almost everytime I order something is always missing lol, I try to get my dasher to check to help make sure everything is there, but I guess I don't mind that much cuz i keep coming back! :) I just love their food so much!! Also my son in law loves the Harvest Chicken Salad (contains pecans) .
L
Leslie J
Emerging Expert • 19 contributions
Loved
• 8/25/25
• DoorDash review
Ordered: The New Yorker ( a deli sandwich) which comes with a side & a pickle spear. The sandwhich came exactly like in the pictures/description. Big & delicious!! I chose chips for my side, but also ordered potato salad because it's sooooo good.
Pro's: Food arrived in perfect/freshly prepared condition (via DoorDash).
Con: McAllister's forgot to include my pickle spear.
**Will I order this sandwich again in future? Yes! Absolutely!**
C
Courtney F
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
Loved
• 11/12/25
• DoorDash order
Broccoli and Cheddar soup was delicious. It was creamy and flavorful. Not too rich--just right.
The Potato Salad was also very good. Nice flavor and texture. Well-seasoned. Has boiled eggs, celery.
I was pleasantly surprised because I didn't have very high expectations but both were delicious. I highly recommend both.
J
Jami E
6 contributions
Loved
• 2/14/26
• DoorDash order
Mardi Gras Cookie was the best! love them!! I love mcalister's they are my go to. I love their chicken and dumpling soup! And I love there kids pizza, it reminds me of the pizza I used to have when I was growing up haha!! Definitely for kids! But everything I've had I've loved!! Hope they keep all my favs heehee!! I do know or assume rather the mardi gras cookie is seasonal, hope they'll bring it back tho!
T
Tristen B
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/19/22
• DoorDash order
Barely any toppings in my sandwich, mostly just ate bread. Not enough dressing is given for the salads. Besides that, food was pretty fresh.
