McAlister's never disappoints. The salads were so fresh (could use an increase in the size of the dressing sent), the potato stayed hot and sandwich covered two meals. Best potato salad in town!
A
Ashley S
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/9/24
• DoorDash order
$75 for a half sandwich/half salad combo and two full size sandwiches?! The "full size" sandwiches were so tiny too. And no pickles included even though all three came with it. Could have had a nice sit down meal with cocktails for that price.
B
Brie T
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/5/25
• DoorDash order
The food was delicious so I hate giving 3 stars but the food preparation was terrible. My buffalo chicken sandwich had barely any chicken on it and the sandwhich was literaly rolled in the paper wrapper instead of the paper being rolled around the sandwich. The BLT was a complete mess and couldnt even be eaten like a sandwich, the ingredients were out side of the bread because it was smashed so much when it was being wrapped. For the amount of money paid this was very disappointing and this is my first experience here.
K
Kerry H
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/27/25
• DoorDash order
My blt was really good and stacked with bacon but my max potato was really lacking. It was like the person who made it had super small hands and did just a pinch of everything. I could fit all the toppings in two spoonfuls.
M
Michelle S
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/31/25
• DoorDash review
Honestly, do not waste your money on delivery from this store. It may be better if you eat fresh at the restaurant, but what we got tonight was horrible and not worth the money spent. My BLT had thin, microwave bacon on it, with basically no avocado on there, and it was on thin, plain white sandwich bread - I could've made a better sandwich at home. The chicken tortilla soup tasted chemically and reheated. Not a true chicken tortilla soup at all - super disappointing and I paid $15 for this soup/sandwich combo. The kids Mac & cheese looked almost grey and mushy, Iwas honestly shocked at how not-fresh everything seemed. The only somewhat good item was the side salad which was fresh, but for the small, side portion it was $7.99 is WAY too steep for mixed greens to be tossed in a to go container. Save yourself the money and cook at home OR spend your money on actual good soup and sanwiches and order Panera.
