I ordered the King Club and it was huge! I ordered it with everything on it, plus the crunchy dill pickle spear on the side and their potato salad, which I had with a prior order. Everything was delicious and freshly made and I will have leftovers for tomorrow! Definitely will be ordering this one in the future.
King Club
C
Catherine S
10 contributions
Loved
• 3/28/26
• DoorDash order
I went with The Rachel Sandwich and it wasvery good and filling! In fact I couldnt finish it!The bread was nice and fresh as well and the dill pickle spear was nice and crisp. I love their food, I've ordered from them a few times. The potato chips I
ordered along with it were crispy kettle chips with sea salt and vinegar. I highly recommend this place!
B
Beatrice H
Emerging Expert • 29 contributions
Liked
• 3 days ago
• DoorDash order
Food here is generally really solid! The Large Potato Salad (8oz) is on par with any local deli, and has flavors of mustard, relish, and onion. The Savannah salad is also pretty great. The Caesar wrap has the potential to be great but both times I ordered it was drenched with dressing to the point it was dripping and the lettuce wilted. There's no way to request light dressing on the DoorDash platform, so I would recommend skipping it.
C
Crystal C
40 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/24/26
• DoorDash order
Reuben and Cuban sandwiches were okay. Country Potato Soup was watery, Chicken Tortilla Soup was good but they didn't give the usual tortilla chips with it. Browniex2 were both old and dry. We were very disappointed. Will have to save the brownies for Jersey Mikes where they are fresh like the use to be here. Will not order here again for awhile.
M
Marsha H
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/2/26
• DoorDash order
Tonight was my first order from McAllister's deli and probably my last. It wasn't terrible, but it wasn't really good. I did the Coose 2 option and ordered a roast beef, cheese, horseradish sandwich. The amount of fillings was pretty meager. I guess the quality was OK, but there wasn't really enough to make a judgment. Somebody decided to add mayo which wasn't on the menu and which I would've eliminated had I been given the option. It was supposed to be on toasted ciabatta bread. Instead, it was on bread that had the consistency/texture of a hamburger bun. Maybe they walked past the toaster as they were taking it out the door, but that would've been the closest it got. The spud was OK… It was a baked potato with a little cheese and bacon on it. The brookie was really good, however.
OK, now I've tried McAllister's.---I'm off to find another new and hopefully better restaurant.
