This is the first I've ordered this...my brother had it and recommended it! It's HUGE...I ate half of a half...it's amazing, everything is so fresh!!
I really like the potato salad, maybe better than my own.
The Lemon Blueberry cookie...with fresh blueberries has an awesome lemon flavor!
The tea is my favorite in town.
To say the least this is one of my favorite restaurants in town...fresh, tasty meals made correctly!!
D
Debra B
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
Loved
• 7/23/25
• DoorDash order
The food was amazing. Ruben had lots of meat. The half roast beef spud was plenty big with a good amount of meat. Only complaint was all the pickles were not in the bag nor was my au jus sauce . The tea was amazing as always, served southern style with just enough strawberry additive to give a hint of flavor without being overpowering .
K
Karalyn J
Local Expert • 20 contributions
Loved
• 4/30/26
• DoorDash order
It is rare that I am genuinely impressed by food I order from Doordash, but McAlister's has seriously done a phenomenal job, and I will be ordering again. I respect and appreciate that they included a slip that lists who prepared the food, who the managers on shift were, and a number to call with any concerns. My food arrived hot and well packaged. I especially appreciate that the pickle was wrapped in cling film so that it didn't leak on the sandwich.
The Reuben tastes great, lots of corned beef and a generous amount of sauerkraut, very tasty sauerkraut at that. It is not overly bitter or pungent, but still sharp and flavorful. I was wary of the Mac & Cheese because it looked like KFC mac, but I was pleasantly surprised to find that it is very cheesy and has a bit of a paprika kick to it. The Colossal Carrot Cake is SOOOOO good, you should 100% add it to your order if you're thinking about it. Really moist, big slice, not too much frosting but the frosting is delicious too.
J
Jordan Y
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/13/25
• DoorDash order
The salad was good but there was a lot of red onion and very little avocado. Personally I would rather pay a little extra like I do at places like Panera to feel like I'm actually fully getting what I paid for
G
Gloria C
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/13/25
• DoorDash order
Ordered the McMcAlister's Club with a side of Potato Salad and a slice of Carrot Cake. The club was mostly Spring Mix, only one quarter of the sandwich had bacon on it. There was only one slice of tomato on the sandwich cut into quarters. The potato salad was my side. There was 3 bites of potato salad in the cup, leaving most of the cup empty. Since there was very little potato salad, it distracted me from the lack of flavor. The Carrot Cake was the only item that was delicious and the portion size was generous.
I had ordered all of these items in the past, and it was delicious, not all Spring Mix and generous portions. So, I ordered it again. What a disappointment and waste of my money.
My next order will be for Carrot Cake only.
