Home
Mehaffies Pies
Mehaffies Pies is not active
This restaurant you are trying to reach is not available on DoorDash right now.Ok
4.5(100+)•
DashPass•
Baking Ohio's best pies and cheesecakes since 1930.•
Store Info
DashPass
4.5(100+)•
$$•Baking Ohio's best pies and cheesecakes since 1930.
Full Catalog
closedReviews
$0.00
delivery fee, first order
to see delivery time
Reviews100+ ratings • 5 public reviews
4.5
of 5 stars
E
Erwin W
Loved
• 8/30/24The absolute best Pecan pie I ever had in my life I swear. apple pie crust was a little bland. But the apples were fresh and flavorful. The Boston Cream slice melts in your mouth. I will be eating alot more pie lol. Love this place ❤️
A
Ann D
Didn't like
• 3/5/24The Mehaffies Pies Pecan Single Slice (5 oz) was too heavy on the vanilla and way to light on actual pecans. The Mehaffies Pies Peanut Butter Single Slice (5 oz) had a weird after taste. The Mehaffies Pies Turtle Cheesecake Slice (5 oz) was ok, but no better than what you can get at Kroger. I was really disappointed and won't be back.
A
April L
Didn't like
• 4/4/24Spong is dry, spice and cinnamon is nice, not enough carr in the Mehaffies Carrot Cake (32 oz). Icing was chewy..
C
Carly C
Loved
• 5/7/26Mehaffies Pies Blueberry Single Slice (5 oz)is usually our favorite, but tonight it was off :/
T
Tiffini E
Didn't like
• 2/15/24the pies arrived so frozen we waited hours for thawing and the Boston cream was just yellow cake