I know they bake their wings so I wasn't expecting the same texture as fried wings, but the skin/fat on these wings was far from baked long enough. They were soft and gelatinous. They're supposed to be double baked but they definitely didn't seem to be. Not to mention it cost almost $50 for 25 wings. Their pizza is great, but I won't ever order the wings again. Lesson learned.
J
John B
Local Expert • 61 contributions
Loved
• 6/13/25
• DoorDash order
Build Your Own Pizza, always a great pie! consistent quality and generous toppings every time. one of the few places that actually give extra cheese.
J
John B
Local Expert • 61 contributions
Loved
• 5/23/25
• DoorDash order
Build Your Own Pizza was delicious. love the crust and toppings were generous.
R
Ryan B
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/18/25
• DoorDash order
i normally get my pizza from mellow mushroom somewhere else but during my stay, i decided to get mellow mushroom in Columbus. A little more mushrooms would have been great.
M
Madison M
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
Liked
• 5/28/26
• DoorDash order
Everything's always good.
We're always the most excited about the new "mellow rolls" but the past two times they've given us 2/3 wrong sauces... it would be okay except for you have to pick multiple sauces.... everything else is always 5/5
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Stone-Baked Pizzas
Our pizzas are made using Classic Mellow crust and are basted with garlic butter and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese. See Gluten-free and Vegan sections for additional pizza offerings. 16 Large - 8 Slices / 14 Medium - 8 Slices / 10 Small - 4 Slices.
Build Your Own Pizza
Build the pizza you love, from crust to finish. 16" Large - 8 Slices / 14" Medium - 8 Slices / 10" Small - 4 Slices.
Munchies
Take a flavor trip. Enjoy Mellow Munchies as starters, meals, or something in between.
Wings
Fly high with crispy, saucy wings baked to absolute perfection.
Salads
Delight your senses in the Garden of Mellow and experience freshness you can see and taste.
Burgers
Our burgers include hand-pressed patties made with 100% black angus beef, served smash style, and can also be ordered bun-less.
Calzones
It’s everything you love about our stone-baked pizzas baked into one delicious masterpiece. Basted in garlic butter, sprinkled with parmesan, and served with a side of Mellow red sauce.
Kids Menu
Vegan
Prefer no meat and no dairy? We got you. From fully vegan pizzas, to salads and more, we have vegans covered.
Certified Gluten-Free
Need a pizza with peace of mind? Our curated selection of stone-baked pizzas can be ordered on our 10” signature GF crust with our certified gluten-free safe procedures (only applicable to items below).
Sweets
A freshly baked selection of tasty treats.
Drinks
Take a sip, take a trip with these refreshing beverages.
