Best pizza I think Ive ever had, used to go to Serafina all the time but kept getting soggy pizzas when ordering take out. First ever take out here pulled up pizza was nice crispy and perfect amount of cheese, second time pizza wasnt up to standard for the store owner and he remade it perfectly for me. Drunken Nonnas might be the best pizza Ive had the chance to put in my mouth. 12 ” option is also perfect for people on budget. Like dead serious best pizza ever cant go no where else anymore. ✌🏼
L
Lindsay P
Local Expert • 46 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/25/26
• DoorDash order
Sadly outside of the pizza, this order was nothing but disappointing. To call this a Penne Alla Vodka with chicken is laughable... there's about a tablespoon of marinara with a tablespoon of chicken (that costs an extra $9.00). The wings were sad and soggy. The only saving grace was the pizza that had a safety sticker that was not secured.
D
Derek B
1 contributions
Loved
• 10/11/25
• DoorDash order
I had a job by Mei Amichi around a year ago and ate lunch there 2-3 times a week. The cheesesteak (#02 Rocky Balboa (Whole) is as good as any cheesesteak I've ever had. It's huge! Ciabatta bread, delicious fried peppers and onions, high quality beef, and perfect white American cheese! And the pizza is absolutely amazing! My favorite is the Nonna style. The sauce is so fresh and delicious, and they put it on top, and it kind of reminds me of bruschetta in the best way! Staff is friendly and courteous! Highly recommended, I go there every time I'm close by!
M
Michelle A
72 contributions
Loved
• 8/16/25
• DoorDash order
Cheese Pie 18" I added my own ingredients and I called the store for a question and the gentleman was so friendly and helpful. when the pizza arrived and we open the box we are New Yorkers, I said to my mom this is a beautiful Pizza! perfectly made beautiful toppings beautiful create my own Cheese Pie 18" just perfect amount of toppings I can't remember this highly enough! please don't ever change! we will be back and thank you for being amazing! this was really needed after a rough day.
J
Jim C
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/8/26
• DoorDash order
After having good experiences with this restaurant, this latest order wasn't so good. This zeppoli came in a paper sack, which was falling apart with grease and no powdered sugar. Totally unedible. I ordered a pepperoni roll, but did not realize I guess I needed to select pepperoni in order to have pepperoni in the roll. I added ingredients and only the black olives and mushrooms made it too. The pepperoni roll. No pepperoni and none of the Italian sausage that I asked for. I am doubtful. I will order again. It's just too expensive to be that unsatisfactory . Wasn't very good.. I kind of got the ideal that no one paid attention to my order so I am hesitant to order again.
