Way better experience than the SouthSide location!
I haven't had Mike & Tony's since visiting their SouthSide spot, and ordering from this location via DoorDash is far superior.
The original Carson Street location is a classic, but dealing with lines and a strict cash-only counter can be a hassle. Getting it delivered from this branch completely changes the game. The food arrives perfectly packaged, hot, and fresh, but with all the convenience of ordering on my phone and paying with a card. The gyro meat and seasoning are just as legendary as I remember, but the overall convenience makes this my new go-to way to get my fix.
J
Jason R
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/6/26
• DoorDash order
This bag of food was so bad it feels like a prank. 14 bucks for 6 tough, rubber Wings (Fresh & Deep Fried) - 6 pc swimming in water sauce that claimed to be Hot Garlic but was neither. The blue cheese was curdled and separated. The fries were loosely wrapped in some dumb paper pouch and therefore all over... why do this? To keep them crispy? They were already soaking wet. And 14 bucks for a gyro the size of a hot dog that was less impressive than if it were a hot dog. This was a dumb bag of food. Mike and Tony's used to be something. This is just a dumb way to spend money.
L
Louisa C
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
Loved
• 5/1/26
• DoorDash order
Best Gyro Salad ever!! Well worth the price and no skimpy portion either!!Huge amount of meat! Loved this!
G
Georgia H
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/8/26
• DoorDash order
Didn't hit like how people hype you up. The steak hoagie was bland and tasteless no flavor at all with little meat. The fries were actually much better than the sandwich which
is sad.
L
Luke A
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/17/26
• DoorDash order
Overpriced and mediocre flavor. Gyro meat has a ton of breading filler to stretch the meat. It didn't even taste like meat anymore . Pierogies were thick dough and undercooked. Very chewy and the only flavor of them was butter. I won't order fom here again.
