15 years of the cheesiest MAC & cheese in Middletown NY! We make over 40 varieties of made to order mac & cheese. Fresh fried mac balls with our cheesy tomato dipping sauce. House made honey cornbre…
The taste of the Garlic "NOTS" B are so delicious! I tried regular and as bacon substitute (I'm not a fan) because the bacon flavor is too strong. The sauce that comes with them is delicious too! I don't like that there's a lot of oil in the container, but nothing a napkin can't soak up. The portion is very filling. This is my second time ordering the balls so clearly they're a little addicting which isn't too great bc of the price. Maybe I'll try the actual Mac and Cheese next!
E
Erika D
Local Expert • 25 contributions
Liked
• 4/5/26
• DoorDash order
I think this was my second favorite Mac and cheese I've had in Orange County. Definitely was worth it and the portion size is great. It wasn't over powered by the maple flavor and the chicken and waffle were great in their own.
V
Valen K
4 contributions
Loved
• 12/10/24
• DoorDash order
Always comes hot and well baked! I love the cauliflower substitute option and of course their Mac Cheddar balls!
H
Heidi K
Local Expert • 88 contributions
Loved
• 12/3/25
• DoorDash order
my first time ever trying their foodanf I have to say 100% in love. the Chicken Cordon Bleu waso tasty and creamy. I tried a smallbite of the Mushroom and it made me weakn the knees. it was so good that's my dinner tonight. the smell mafe my mouth water. I can't wait to try other flavors.
D
Danielle W
1 contributions
Loved
• 8/12/26
• DoorDash order
thank you for such great Mac and cheese 🧀 ❤️ with no bread crumbs. it's perfection. American Mac and cheese is just the best here! try it if you haven't yet.
