This Reese's Cup Layered Sundae is my new obsession. Switch the vanilla for chocolate custard and you are set. So good and large. I'm unable to eat it in one sitting
A
Anissa G
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 6 days ago
• DoorDash order
Ordered the Cookie Monster ice cream and was pretty disappointed. It’s an eye-searing, artificial shade of blue with barely any actual Oreo mixed through — just a few sparse crumbs. The cookie dough pieces weren’t distributed at all; they were all clumped at the bottom of the cup instead of mixed in. There was also a strange aftertaste that made it hard to finish. Texture and flavor both felt like an afterthought compared to the color.
I only came here because it’s one of the few places open late — but Sundaes Homemade does a genuinely great Cookie Monster ice cream that this doesn’t come close to. Paying $14 for something that tastes this artificial isn’t worth it. Won’t be returning.
T
Tasheena H
1 contributions
Loved
• 5/26/26
• DoorDash order
I tasted it first before I took a picture. You see how much I ate before I got the pizza in. I would definitely order again. The waffle is delicious. The ice cream is delicious.
J
Jessica R
9 contributions
Loved
• 2/13/26
• DoorDash order
I've tried a bunch of different hard ice creams from Mueller's and honestly I haven't found one I don't like yet! The Mint Chocolate Chip is my favorite though
N
Nicole D
11 contributions
Liked
• 3/11/26
• DoorDash order
Graham Central Station with chocolate crunchies. SO delicious! If you like graham crackers and chocolate, you'll love this! tastes eexactly like a graham cracker
