Enjoy the best pizza in Williamsville/Lancaster like the locals do. Local residents have made Muscarella's Pizza one of the most popular in the area. Sample what they have to offer and see if you agre…
Ordered a large pizza with pepperoni and garlic Parmesan crust plus BBQ Chicken Fingers for my significant other. It did not state that the fingers came with fries but that was a welcome addition. This was SUPER good. 10/10 from me. Will definitely order from Muscarella's in the future.
J
Jacki S
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/23/26
• DoorDash order
Small Pizza (C+1 Topping) & 10 Wings
Pizza was out of this world. very good!
Wings were ordered mild, but they were so plain. No flavor and not cooked extra crispy as ordered. They were otherwise cooked really well. I'll get the pizza again.
Sub Half: Ham Sahlens
very dry! Hardly any mayo on it (and I didn't request light mayo). But otherwise, it was good.
BBQ French Fries
These have a kick to it. Fries were not salted, so it lacked something. Basically dipping soggy potatoes into a jar of BBQ sauce. I still ate them, but I won't order them again.
Christopher R
Emerging Expert • 40 contributions
Loved
• 6/28/25
• DoorDash order
Very good, solid, medium thicc buffalo pizza. Extremely fresh and bountiful toppings. The Italian wings were top notch. Really good chicken meat.
C
Corey C
1 contributions
Liked
• 5/17/26
• DoorDash order
Probably my top three favorite 'zas in Buffalo. The garlic parm crust is a game changer.
J
Jennifer H
2 contributions
Loved
• 1/19/26
• DoorDash order
Pizza is delicious. Baked perfectly. Sauce has magic in it
