"It's been claimed that the American success story is built on producing and releasing a product that the market has been waiting for. Nancy and Rocco Palese's success with stuffed pizza is their stor…
This is hands-down the best pizza in the area. I dont't know what the secret is but we order from Nancy's now and no longer have to drive to Italian Ovens all the way out in Round Lake Beach to get pizza as delicious as this is!
J
Jennifer T
Local Expert • 72 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/29/24
• DoorDash order
First, I would not have ordered from here if I hadn't had a gift card because the prices are pretty steep and the pizza sizes aren't listed in inches. The pizza was alright. The crust was too thick and floppy to be thin crust, it sb crispy and it was not, the inner crust slices were soggy and seemed raw. The sauce was so bland, not bad, just bland. No spice, no tomato zing, no taste. There were a good amount of toppings, and they were tasty and fresh, the sausage was good, but the dice on the onion and green pepper was way too large - so the pizza was ok but not balanced. Their cheese was generous and high quality and the fresh basil added much needed flavor. It was an acceptable pizza but overpriced and not up to the high standards for pizza in Chicagoland. If you served this pizza in say, Nebraska, they might love it. But we know great pizza here. And this just wasn't great pizza, as it should have been for the price. Sorry Nancy, I'm not impressed and I won't be back.
T
Terri R
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/16/24
• DoorDash review
Won't go back paid over $70 for the
To give us literaly 8 waffle fries . Its absurd to drop that kind of moneysnd you get 8 fries .
A
Amber M
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/8/26
• DoorDash order
Bone-in Chicken Wings were cooked but have no crisp to them. 12" Medium Classic Thin Crust Pizza had minimal flavor and honestly I would have preferred the Jewel take and bake pizza.
L
LAURA L
4 contributions
Liked
• 12/10/24
• DoorDash order
The thin crust pizza and the meatballs were spot on! delicious 😋. I wasn't very impressed with the mozzarella sticks but that's probably in part due to them no longer being warm when my dasher got here (no one's fault, I'm just a bit of a drive away).
