It has often been said that the American success story is based on inventing and introducing a product for which the public has been waiting. The success of the stuffed pizza is the story of Nancy and…
Nancy's brings a nostalgic feeling about me. If you like Chicago Pizza, this is the place. The Godfather with au jus to dip in was excellent. I love the choice to dip your bread, instead of dipping for me. The 9" Small Original Stuffed Pizza, 10" Small Classic Thin Crust Pizza which was loaded with meat was excellent. Overall, great pizza.
D
Dana W
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/1/25
• Commande DoorDash
Had this been my first time ordering with Nancy's this would have been my last order. I ordered the Spaghetti & Meatballs, Side of Meatballs, Italian Meatball Sub, and a stuffed pizza. The Side of Meatballs has always came with sauce, this time it did not and meatballs were dry. The Spaghetti & Meatballs were also lacking sauce and again the meatballs were dry. The person who ate the Italian Meatball Sub had the same complaint of lack of sauce and dry. The pizza as always was fine. And our breadsticks were shorted I ordered and paid for 6 but was given 3. For $140 I expected them to meet their normal standards at the bare minimum. I'm going to assume maybe it was just a busy Tuesday night. If you do end up having issues with Nancy's don't bother with calling them. They will basically assume you're lying and brush you off.
J
Janique S
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/26/25
• Commande DoorDash
I spent $60 on 1 pizza that was delivered lopsided resulting in all toppings only on half the pizza, the other half has nothing on it. The cardboard box was soaked into the pizza giving it a cardboard taste. This is the second time I've ordered from here and both times there have been quality issues. I would not recommend ordering from here. You pay too much money for it to be poor quality.
M
Magnolia S
Local Expert • 28 contributions
Loved
• 5/2/25
• Commande DoorDash
This Cesar salad is my new fav!! The dressing is amazing . I love the mix of arugula and romaine ! My new favorite restaurant for Cesar salads !
Z
Zackery M
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/28/25
• Commande DoorDash
Fettuccine Alfredo is good, my Boneless Chicken Wings only came with 7 rather than 8. Which is a bummer. From now on im sticking with the pizza and breadsticks only. If I order from here again that is.
