The best National Coney Island in my area! Everytime I get these Hanis from any other National, they do not taste right and seems they don't put much cheese or ranch on the Hani. This place makes it perfect, warm when it gets to me and also give me pickles which I love!!! Any other place it's like pulling teeth to get those pickles!
T
Theresa S
Local Expert • 79 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/8/25
• DoorDash order
My $7.20 BOWL of Chicken Lemon Rice Soup was half of a container and 95% of it was water.
Not the Lemon Rice Soup itsed to be. The Gyros sandwich on Pita Bread was barely warm let alone hot. Onions were large slices and there was a little amount of meat. I would not recommend this $10
Gyros sandwich to anyone who loves an awesome Gyros. Very disappointed with NATIONAL CONEY ISLAND anymore.
What happened to Mr. Jim's famous coney place?
T
Theresa S
Local Expert • 79 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/4/25
• DoorDash order
My GYRO was burned. The meat was actually charred and tasted burned. It was hard when I bit into it. The taziki sauce was tasteless. All you could taste was the burnt meat. The milkshake was a joke. It might have fit in a shot glass and I was charged $6 for it?
What a joke that was!
I've come to the conclusion that these coney island places aren't worth a cent. They're getting worse by the day. A Hot Fudge Sundae with NO HOT FUDGE?? Pure Iaziness.
I won't waste my time or money at any of them.
A
Aaron S
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/23/23
• DoorDash order
I ordered a buffalo chicken Crispy Buffalo Ranch Chicken Sandwich and it was soggy and tasted like nasty like grill grease. Also ordered a Fish Sandwich and that wasn't very good either. Maybe it's just a bad day for them but yikes I spent 20$ on food I'd thought would be made how it usually is. On top of all of that I got one napkin.
A
Alysha r
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/21/25
• DoorDash order
Omelet was cold/lukewarm and I paid extra to get it delivered first to avoid this problem, the cheese wasn't even melted properly.
Got skimped on the bacon for the bfast wrap as well which we made only a blt so that's the whole point of the dish...
Very disappointed in this location
