History
Since 1927, Erie has had a New York Lunch tradition. At the ages of 34 and 30, Stephen and Nina purchased the business in January 1970. They've worked together every day since, and they're now…
I ordered the Lunch Special which comes with 1 Greek dog, 1 greek hamburger, a small order of greek fries and a drink and the price was unbeatable! I added cheese to my fries and topped it all off with a peanut butter Milkshake it was delicious and MUCH bigger than I thought it would be. Loads of whipped cream! This was the best food I've ordered in quite a while! 10/10 would definitely recommend! Also, everything was packaged well and housed in separate bags put into another bag and marked that it was safety sealed.
A
Aisling S
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
Loved
• 1/25/25
• DoorDash order
This is the best food i think i have ever had in erie. I was excited to surprise my husband with greek fries and a good omlet, and he was extremely impressed. The food was delicious (obviously), fresh and hot, and almost too much to finish as the proportions are spectacular for the price. I hope this place never leaves they do amazing work!! Im especially obsessed with the chocolate shake!
A
Adi T
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Liked
• 5/20/26
• DoorDash order
Nina's Homemade Chicken Noodle Soup is always fantastic and so delicious! I don't think I've had anything from this place that isn't awesome, though. I will say, the fried mushrooms never come with the sauce as advertised although they are also pretty tasty.
L
Louie D
1 contributions
Loved
• 10/19/24
• DoorDash order
Greek Omelette was good it was good but it was BIG i didn't finish it it was enough for two people serving size was enough they do not skimp out on anything the best Greek Omelette ive had Mega Yeeros (Gyros) The gyro was GINORMOUS it came in time and the beautiful meledoy of cooked vegetables and mushrooms they put love into their food. The last bite contained tomatoes, banana peppers, and mushroom. I thank God for whoever came up with that mixture of ingredients on a lamb gyro Thank you New York Lunch Compliments to the Chef and the Dasher. I would give this place 1,000,000 stars 🤩⭐⭐ god bless and take care. Love always , Louie 💋
K
Kylene H
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
Loved
• 11/6/25
• DoorDash order
This place has *THE* best Yeeros (Gyros) in town, hands down! Their lamb is so perfectly seasoned and they arent afraid of extra Tzatziki sauce when I ask for it. And, their cheese fries taste like they are from the boardwalk at the jersey shore. Heaven!
