The supreme pizza tasted great and was more than enough to feed a group. The crust toward the outside was perfect, the center was a bit soft just because of how many toppings there were and how big the pizza was. The cheesecake was also good, great texture if a little bland. Would order from here again for sure!
A
Amy D
3 contributions
Loved
• 2/18/23
• DoorDash review
A friend of mine (Leida) suggested we get pizza from here. I had not heard of this place, but definitely trust her opinion as I have had her cooking. I gave it a shot and was far from disappointed. I typically can't get past 2 slices pizza. My husband and I ordered the supreme and the florentine in medium's. I have 1 slice left. Its refreshing to have a pizza place around where you can taste the freshness of the products they use. By far the best pizza I have had. I have change my regular pizza place permanently. No other place will compare.
L
Leida M
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
Loved
• 8/26/22
• DoorDash order
Ever since I moved here from VA my family and I will only eat from NY NY Pizza. You guys never disappoint us. Pizza is always fresh and not greasy just like a real New York Pizza! The cheese pizza is very cheesy and the Meat Lovers is marvallous!
S
Stephen B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/16/23
• DoorDash order
Save your money. Charged $4 per topping for barely a sprinkle of anything ordered. Garlic bread was just plain bread, and the pasta combo came as more of a slop
G
Gwen R
12 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/15/23
• DoorDash order
4 jalapeno poppers for $10??? This was such a rip off. I can't believe they don't list how many items are in what you're ordering. For that price, I expected at least 8 pieces. You get 5 for $5 literally everyone else. Somehow the onions rings were wet and he cheesecake was dry. Ruined the entire experience.
