Was absolutely fantastic! I ordered a Cheee (10" Small) pizza and wished I ordered a large. The light bake crust was perfect, the cheese was thick and so gooey! The best have had in a long time! The spaghetti with meat sauce was delicious! It was hot, fresh, great quality! I will definitely be ordering from here again soon. Would absolutely recommend!!
J
Jennifer L
2 contributions
Loved
• 2/15/26
• DoorDash order
Amazing pizza!!! We wanted something quick and tasty and boy did they deliver!!! The add-ons were a little pricier but well worth it. They didn't skimp on the meat or veggies. You can taste the high quality products they use at first bite. The pizzas are large so will allow for leftovers. Highly recommend.
J
Judith M
2 contributions
Loved
• 2/8/26
• DoorDash order
I absolutely recommend New York Pizza! I went there the first time after reading other reviews. This place has authentic Italian food. Best quality ingredients.
I have had the Spinach Lasagna, Manicotti, pizza, and Stuffed shells. The salads are supreme. My favorite is the Stuffed Shells.
I'm placing my order now.
L
Lewis P
4 contributions
Didn't like
• today
• DoorDash order
The chocolate chip pizza was not fully cooked, the dough center was raw and inedible.
The photo makes it look like a giant cookie, made with cookie dough, which was a bit misleading. The picture does not match what was received.
Also, the pricing is very misleading. It looks like you are adding $12.49 to your order for a small, but you are adding $12.49 to the "base price" which makes the price $24.98. A ridiculous order mechanism and a ridiculous price.
B
Brady M
2 contributions
Liked
• 1/23/26
• DoorDash order
They did not see my instructions to put the olives on the side. But they re-made my order immediately and had it for me in 10 mins! Great food too!
