New York Pizza Pie
4.5(200+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info•
DashPass
Temporarily closed
Order for later
4.5(200+)•
Pizzeria
Full Menu
11:00 am - 8:10 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
XL Cheese & Pepperoni
$23.97
XL Cheese
$21.45
Regular Cheese
$17.66
Regular The New Yorker
$23.97
Regular The Manhattan
$23.97
Regular 112 Margherita
$23.97
Reviews200+ ratings • 40+ public reviews
4.5
of 5 stars
K
Keirsten H
15 contributionsLiked
• 7/29/26OmiLordy !!!! NEVER DISAPPOINTS ME !! Delishness !! Big slices!!! Freshly made !!! All of my choices are fresh and specifically placed on the pizza !!! Definitely worth ordering again!! YAY !!!
P
Paul C
Local Expert • 49 contributionsLoved
• 5/8/25I love the crust. Tastes like new york city brick oven thin crust with pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, and pepperonni. I give this 18" Pepperoni Pizza 9.5/10. If you are in Birmingham area this is a must!
A
Aaron L
4 contributionsDidn't like
• 5/3/26This pizza was a disappointment,the pizza itself was way too thin which lead to the actual crust being under cooked. flavor was there but unfortunately they are too thin on everything and cheese. pizza flavored paper and for the price not worth it. I grew up in NYC and this is not it.
A
Ashley B
Emerging Expert • 13 contributionsLoved
• 2/28/25Born and raised in **central** NY and it's been so hard to find a pizza that tastes nearly as good. This pizza was pretty darn close!!! The crust is SO good by itself!!! Doesn't need a bunch of grease and seasonings to make it edible. I am so grateful I tried something new cause this place did NOT disappoint! Will definitely be ordering again soon!
K
Keirsten H
15 contributionsLoved
• 5/12/26OMIGOODNESS!!!! First order and IT IS SO DARN DELICIOUS !!! I will be eating this for dinner, breakfast, lunch and dinner until it is gone !!! The xlarge is definitely XL !!! The freshness is delightful!!! Definitely will order again !!!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store