Order Nicholas Creamery - Tinton Falls, NJ Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices] | Tinton Falls - DoorDash
4.9(200+)•
DashPass•
Ice Cream & Gelato
•
Store Info
DashPass
4.9(200+)•
$$•Ice Cream & Gelato
Nicholas Creamery was born out of a love for homemade ice cream, handcrafted recipes and a desire to take something we all know and love and bring it back to its purest form.
We are 100% in love wit…
The best ice cream in NJ! Id give 5 stars but they need to normalize their hot fudge portions when delivering. Sometimes you get enough for your sundae, sometimes you get barely 2 tablespoons. I'll probably just go in person when the fam is in the mood for sundaes.
M
Mary S
Local Expert • 68 contributions
Loved
• 8/7/25
• DoorDash review
The ice cream was amazing! This place is like heaven on earth. I highly recommend it. The portions were amazing as well, huge even! The ice cream was so fresh and creamy, we enjoyed all the ice cream we ordered and hope to order more of their other sweet treats. Although the price is very high for said ice cream, it really is worth it.... Give them a chance they have a flavor for everybody!
A+
Mary S
M
Mary S
Local Expert • 68 contributions
Loved
• 9/26/25
• DoorDash order
I had to inhale the ice cream.The second I got it.So I have no pictures, but this place is truly, the garden of eden of ice cream. It is super pricey, but is small badge and the freshest best ice cream in the world and the portions are actually pretty good for the cost! I would definitely order again.This place is legendary!Mint Chocolate Chunk Good Ole Fashioned Chocolate
B
Becky E
Emerging Expert • 40 contributions
Liked
• 3/4/26
• DoorDash order
the Cookie Butter (Limited Edition!) was delicious,great texture. Kelly’s Pineapple Cake (Limited Edition!) missed the target. Texture was completely off, would not order again.
B
Bruce G
6 contributions
Liked
• 3/14/26
• DoorDash order
Great ice cream and sides. Dubai's and Peanut Butter palooza were awesome.
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Water
Sundae Funday Kit
The Ultimate SUNDAE FUNDAY KIT
Why choose happiness when you can order it?
For $30 get everything you need to throw your own Nicholas Creamery Sundae Party:
3 crowd pleasing pints (your choice!)
Our famous hot fudge (IYKYK)
2 Toppings (Your Choice!)
Small batch. Big flavor. Zero movement required. Hit order and let the Sundae Funday commence.
Ice Cream Flights
Four homemade, small batch ice cream scoops (your choice!)
