Nicky's Undefeated is serving up the very best cheesesteaks, and hoagies, and Italian American classics in the Southeast. It was founded by two friends who have both lived in Atlanta for 20 years but …
Full Menu
10:45 am - 8:40 pm
Featured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
WHOLE Beef Cheesesteak
$28.90
•88% (18)
HALF Beef Cheesesteak (Save $ Get the Whole not the Half)
$17.90
•90% (50)
#2 Most liked
WHOLE Veggie Hoagie
$28.00
WHOLE Ham & Cheese Hoagie
$27.00
HALF Ham & Cheese Hoagie (Save $ Get the Whole not the Half)
$20 (would have been 29 had I not had Door dash perks unlocked) before tip for a Decent 6in sub is ridiculous. It was delicious and im not a miser but arguably the same if not better (depending on location) is under 20 for a loaded 12" for ~16$. The cost is just not justifiable. The only thing undefeated is their price to post-hunger ratio. Hate to give a poor review but it's just belly robbery haha. Have to say, their hot peppers are the Jam. Please don't take my review as a reason not to order, just plan to ball out for a delicious submarine.
J
Joey M
1 contributions
Loved
• 9/19/25
• DoorDash order
EVERYTHING WAS DELICIOUS , crispy delicious Mozzarella Squares , quality cheese ! The FRIES Regular were delicious , seasoned and a nice size . The HALF Beef Cheesesteak is HUGE !! And the cheese sauce OMG !!! So good
K
Karl S
5 contributions
Loved
• 5/25/25
• DoorDash order
the real deal. I grew up in a small suburb of Philly called North Delaware. The chewy roll keeps it from getting soggy. prime cuts of chicken and beef. The wiz is the wiz and y'all ain't ready for Cooper sharp cheese down here.
it's not just a legit Philly place, it competes the best South Philly joints I've ever been to
M
Michael L
2 contributions
Loved
• 11/6/24
• DoorDash review
Great Cheesesteaks loaded with steak, cheese on a really good roll. Hoagies are loaded too. Packed well. Great for delivery.
C
Christine H
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/9/26
• DoorDash order
Not sure why this sandwich is $30 it's absolutely bland, no seasoning, no cheese despite it being a cheesesteak, no dressing, no mayo, nothing but dry bread, unflavored meat. The bread does not taste fresh. The meat tastes tough and gross. I would not order here again or recommend. The sub size is large but who wants a large nasty bland dry sub? No one. The only thing I appreciate was the sealed packaging.
