This was our first time. Everything was fantastic. I ordered the buffalo chicken salad and they put the chicken on the side to keep the salad fresh and crispy! It was the best I ever had. My wife had the Mixed green salad and she loved it and made 3 meals out of it. The soup was delicious and the rolls they sent were still hot soft and a little crispy on the outside. The mini canolis again were fantastic! Shells crispy cream was not too sweet and they added the perfect amount of powdered sugar. We have not had a take out meal this good in a long long time if ever. Next time to try the pizza! very excited!
E
Erin C
Emerging Expert • 35 contributions
Liked
• 4/5/26
• DoorDash order
The best! As always! The family meal deal always hits the spot and is an awesome value! I was a little tiny bit, disappointed that they don't include two salad dressings and a little more vegetables in their salads, the salad itself is actually big so you do need two salad dressings! Their food is always on point, quality ingredients, it's not that slimy thin, deli pepperoni that every other pizzeria uses, it's thick hand, cut, and delicious… Same with their sausage that they put on their pizza… Fresh fresh fresh vegetables, quality stretchy cheese that reheats like it's brand new, this place is always five stars and for some reason it's way how higher quality and a lot cheaper than other places
E
Erin C
Emerging Expert • 35 contributions
Liked
• 2/21/26
• DoorDash order
This is by far the best pizza around… New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania. Always uses high-quality ingredients and the best for the price… I live in Warwick, New York and the pizza year is just garbage and cost double at least. They did undercook it this time for some reason probably because I ordered through DoorDash and they were in a hurry, otherwise? This place is top-notch and will never order from anywhere else.
E
Erin C
Emerging Expert • 35 contributions
Loved
• 3/27/25
• DoorDash order
The Bella Vista pizza. I added extra cheese and asked for oregano also. If I could give Nonna's 10 stars, I would. They are always consistent in quality, and preparing the orders correctly. They actually use REAL cup and char pepperoni, the thick stuff, as opposed to that slimy thin deli crap. Their cheese heats up like brand new the next day, as its quality cheese.
Good job, Nonna's and staff! THANK YOU!
K
Karen L
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
Liked
• 10/11/24
• DoorDash order
Everything we ordered from Nonna's was delicious. We ordered Wings which were nice & crispy. The Chicken Fingers & fries were tasty. The Nonna's Favorite Salad with grilled chicken was filling and refreshing . The Nonna’s Plain Pizza & Personal Pizza were nice & thin with a well done crust just the way we ordered it. I gave 4 stars only because the extra cheese does not appear to be on the pepperoni half as ordered(2nd time).
