Awesome! I got the pork tenderloin with roasted sweet potatoes and Brussel sprouts and it was amazing and cooked to perfection! I wish they would add it permanently to the menu. I actually got it the first time the other day and while it was good it wasn't nearly as good as this time, guess it depends on who the cook is that day, sadly. But NYAJ consistently impresses me. I'm a regular.
P
Pam D
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/29/25
• DoorDash order
Small Pizza was tiny. More Personal size. Nachos mashed into tiny to go container. Soggy beyond belief. Wontons missing the white sauce.
Not impressed really.
D
Dee S
Emerging Expert • 21 contributions
Loved
• 2/3/25
• DoorDash order
I am obsessed with the MUSTARD-CRUSTED CHICKEN and order it frequently. It is so good! I wouldn't mind if they started to peel their mashed potatoes and season the green beans a bit, but I still plan on keeping this as one of my local go-to comfort foods. Caesar salad is always crisp and yummy, too!
W
William D
Emerging Expert • 60 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/2/25
• DoorDash order
The BBQ MEATLOAF was burnt on the bottom and thus not to tasty. Half of it was edible. The mashed potatoes and carrots were good. The onion strings other the being cold were tasty after I heated them up in my air fryer
L
Lena B
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/31/24
• DoorDash order
The CAPE COD REUBEN Sandwich does a lot right. the slaw and the fish are made very well. However the cheese almost completely overpowers any of the flavors of the fish and slaw. You mainly only taste the cheese and bread with the texture of a soft fish. The potato salad is great but mild, as in not tense in tang or sweet just mild. The STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE is great no notes. I don't like super sweet things. And this is a great dessert if you more like milder sweets. The biscuit is spongey not dry which soaks the tangy sweet strawberry sauce well. The whipcream is a nice compliment to both the sauce and the bread. However, once you add the ice cream to the combo, it's the perfect dessert. Side note, put the ice cream between the 2 halves of the biscuit it's literally like a strawberry STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE ice cream sandwich. It's like a nice little treat for yourself.
