We absolutely LOVE the wings from NYC! All flavors are good but we love the mango habanero and lemon le the best.
The 16" - Large Sweet Ricotta Pepperoni cup is the BEST pizza. Amazing crust!
K
Krista W
2 contributions
Loved
• 10/31/25
• DoorDash order
Sweet tea for a cup was almost 5 dollars, was not worth buying that. Big ziti was absolutely to die for. I got the pepperoni and sausage 12 and it was awesome. The only thing was I did not care for the actual crust. And I saw that thing on their menu in regards to thin crust. 
A
Ashley G
2 contributions
Loved
• 8/25/25
• DoorDash order
I usually don't leave reviews but the food was soooooo good. Cheese pizza was phenomenal. the garlic butter sauce and ranch sauce tasted homemade and also really good. Sad I didn't get the Shirley temple I ordered though 
D
Dana F
Emerging Expert • 101 contributions
Liked
• 7/23/25
• DoorDash order
This was our first time ordering.
I have mixed feelings. It was a little pricey. My husband really liked his Baked Baked Spaghetti .
I had Stromboli Pepperoni and was disappointed. It was burned. I know that stromboli's crust is brown and crispy, but this was burned, black. So much so that I couldn't eat it.
We will order again, I just can not recommend the Stromboli Pepperoni .
S
Shannon F
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
Liked
• 3/17/25
• DoorDash order
So, we've been going to NYC for a long time and it's always delicious. getting on door dash hasn't changed that. but my garlic knots were put into the bag sideways...like, I'm not sure if the bag was meant to be laid on its side on top of the box, but the grease got all over! saturated the bottom of the bag, the top of the pizza box and dripped everywhere when I went to throw the bag away. don't get me wrong, everything was so good, as always, but multiple people handled my order and didn't wonder why the bag was totally soaked in grease?12" - Medium Pickle Ranch Famous NYC Garlic Knots
