Authentic NYC-style pizza and Italian favorites in the heart of St. Augustine. From our signature hand-rolled meatballs and jumbo wings to specialty pies like the "Hot Honey Hustle," we bring the bold…
I work near NYC Meatballs & Pizzeria and have ordered delivery and pickup, every time the pizza is hot and delicious! The staff is always nice & helpful! It's a great pizza place!!
D
Donna T
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
Loved
• 3/8/26
• DoorDash order
One of the best chicken Parm I've had in a really long time. Actually came with two whole chicken breast not tiny little cut up pieces that people usually try to fit as little as they can into the sandwich. This store is an A+ plus highly recommended I will definitely be back.
M
Michael L
10 contributions
Loved
• 3/22/26
• DoorDash review
Rocky aways comes through, was there when he opened in Oakleaf years ago and so thrilled he had a new place in St Augustine. Incredible pizza, monster wings and the best garlic knots anwhere in the south.
L
Lisa M
5 contributions
Liked
• 6 days ago
• DoorDash order
16" Large Margherita Mulberry pizza was perfect! Love the thin crust and fresh mozzarella.
We also got the Penne Pasta with Vodka sauce. It was just Ok, sauce was spicy but no other flavor and the pasta tasted very starchy as if it was cooked a day ahead. The side salad with house dressing was delicious and their homemade garlic bread was a nice side.
M
Marla V
22 contributions
Liked
• 9/19/26
• DoorDash order
Baked Ziti was good. Good flavor and well packaged. I didn't get any marinara with the Famous NYC Garlic Knots and they also forgot the extra marinara sauce I payed for. They also didn't give any dressing for the side salads. Had to eat a dry salad. This is the second time this has happened with our to-go order.
