The "Brookie" is me and my son's absolute favorite! He is autistic and eats the "brownie" pasty out of it lol but it is so exquisite!! The cookies are well worth the price!! I usually have to 1/2 them to eat in a single setting
Jacqueline M
119 contributions
Loved
• 5/6/26
• DoorDash order
Banana Whoopie Pie was exceptionally delicious. you really nailed this one. it was so decadent and yummy. glad I ordered two lol big cookies and fresh!! I've ordered from them dozens of times in the past and I will continue ordering from them in the future when I want a treat.
Jacqueline M
119 contributions
Loved
• 9/11/25
• DoorDash order
Banana Cream Pie cookies are my new favorite of all time. they are so big and super fresh and I love the banana cream frosting on top of the cookie. I've already ordered twice this month lol so divine and decadent.
E
Elicia P
Emerging Expert • 26 contributions
Liked
• 4/30/25
• DoorDash order
Cookies are delicious, but the lemon glaze was only a small amount right in the middle. Way less than ones I got in the past, and nothing like the picture. The glaze is the best part imo
M
Michelle K
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/13/24
• DoorDash order
First time trying, kids input included:
chocolate chip: a good solid recipe keep this one
dark chocolate sea salt: kiddo thought it was too salty, it is best if you put it on top of your tongue so the chocolate is enhanced by the salt. good cookie
cookies n' cream: ok cookie. not bad, not spactacular. needs some kind of flavor enhancement: vanilla? chocolate? more salt?felt like a missed opportunity.
caramel macchiato: missing the coffee flavor. lots of caramel and vanilla, decent cookie.
blueberry muffin: juicy blueberries, nice crumble topping, very moist. I liked it, kids not so much.
NY cheesecake: the only cookie my ten year old spit out. maybe it was the cheesecake center that was really moist in it, maybe it was the overall flavor. Think a chocolate chip cookie base with no chocolate and a lump of cream cheese filling in the center. very moist. not bad.
