The SICILIAN PEPPERONI ROLLS™ and the FIRECRACKER SHRIMP were delicious and had a good portion of food. The BONELESS CHICKEN WINGS TALL however had only 5 chicken nugget sized wings. Maybe they thought I ordered a small? But it had less chicken by weight than the weight of the shrimp dish, which doesn't make sense bc the wings were more expensive and chicken is cheaper per pound than shrimp. I expected to see 3x the amount of chicken I received. It was still really good, just very few.
N
Nathan B
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/16/25
• DoorDash order
SIDE MEDITERRANEAN SALAD was fine. I'll admit when it comes to the CRAFT YOUR OWN PIZZA I could have read more clearly what I was buying. However an individual pizza for $23 is insane. For that money I could have bought more pizza that had flavor anywhere else in Bozeman for the same money.
I also find it concerning on one of the CRAFT YOUR OWN PIZZA the directions asked for green onion and I had green peppers. Not a concern for my party but if someone has an allergy and they are specifically asking for something and something else is put on that is a concern.
I will not order from Old Chicago again. Very disappointing pricing and portion. If I'm spending money for pizza for guests, I'll take my business to red tractor and I will recommend that for anyone buying pizza in the valley. At least you spend a lot of money for good quality and quantity pizza!
D
Daniel J
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/14/25
• DoorDash order
Burnt. No lid on the sauce, so it was just everywhere. Didn't have my dessert in stock. Which is fine, but any other restaurant would just substitute it or call and ask me what resolution we can agree to. Instead I got a handwritten note saying they are out and I have to go through DoorDash support to get a refund.
E
Ella B
2 contributions
Loved
• 9/16/25
• DoorDash order
Phenomenal chicken, perfect for a late night bite. It was hot, tender, and a huge portion. I will absolutely be ordering again.
J
John L
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/13/24
• DoorDash order
The order was ridiculously small even for a child. The chicken was skimpy, dry and over seasoned and the fries were reheated frozen Sysco garbage.
