The sandwiches, pies, and sides at Old Moon Deli & Pie are amazing.
They always hit the perfect spot, whether they're classic or contemporary.
Our sandwiches, which range from Reuben to Monte Christo …
The sandwiches were delicious. The bread was excellent. The Greek sandwich was really an interesting and yummy mix of flavors. I wouldn't order the fruit cup again, because it was small for the price. But we will definitely be back for more sandwiches and pie!
M
Mary Alice W
Local Expert • 76 contributions
Loved
• 5/30/26
• DoorDash order
I loved the Reuben with Russian dressing & the Big Muff was good too. I like the potato salad...if I was at home I'd add a spoon of mayo to it. It's more of a German style potato salad. Delivery was excellent to my hotel room via DoorDash. Well packaged and arrived delicious.
R
Rex R
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/10/26
• DoorDash order
taste wise thumbs up
but 16 plus bucks for a quarter of a sandwich that's called The Big Muff, 6 plus for barely more than a mc donalds dip worth of Potato Salad? I get places add a bit for for doordash but this is ridiculous and frankly turns me off to even visit in person.
V
Valerie M
5 contributions
Loved
• 1/29/23
• DoorDash order
This place is always amazing and has a variety of choices for vegetarians and non alike.
Staff is always friendly and helpful when you can't decide on what to get. My goto sandwich is the Cuban and I also love the Southern Lady.
M
Melinda T
19 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/13/25
• DoorDash order
I originally ordered egg salad and it was replaced with chicken salad which had more mayo than anything else. I don't particularly like chicken salad anyway. Given no choice in the matter. Very little fruit for the 4.99 price tag.
