Best chicken parm sammiches we've had on a very long time! Perfectly crisp breading, juicy chicken, and plenty of cheese. All of this on a premium bun. The onion rings and breaded mushrooms were also great. We'll definitely order again!
V
Victoria T
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Loved
• 10/19/25
• DoorDash order
Had some friends in from out of town who missed "Chicago Pizza". Best pizza in the NW burbs. They give you generous ingredient portions, so fresh, still hot, and they even took note to bake it well done. It's now saved as a forever favorite. This was true to Chicago's tavern-style lovers.
F*ing DELISH!!!
J
Jason K
Emerging Expert • 41 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/13/25
• DoorDash review
The fried chicken is awesome! Crispy and cooked perfectly. This time they barely gave us any fries with it. The pizza was probably the worst pizza I have had ever. Had a weird taste and others complained it tasted bland. The pics looked amazing. We were pretty disappointed. The food is usually good from there. First and last time we will order pizza from there.
B
Belinda R
6 contributions
Liked
• 3/21/25
• DoorDash order
I order pizza here often and imo Old Town has the BEST pizza in the Schaumburg area. And I will continue ordering pizza from them. However -
Bc their pizza is so good, we figured their pasta would be, too.
It is not. We ordered spaghetti with marinara,and eggplant Parmesan. Both were lower end of mid. Edible, but not that enjoyable. The sauce tastes like it's from a can.
We also ordered Breaded Mushrooms and those were good. Again the sauce for them- the same marinara- was just ok.
But I'm giving this restaurant 4 stars bc the pizza is that good. It's phenomenal.
So order the pizza here. Get pasta elsewhere.
M
Mick G
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/10/26
• DoorDash order
First off I don't like to review badly instead I would just rather not order again but this is deserving I ordered 18 a inch pizza they had on special it was sausage and pepperoni the pizza had extremely tiny bits of sausage and many many cuts of the pizza had zero sausage and very little cheese it was extremely dry so I've ordered many times in the past moral of this review is they cut back their ingredients if you get a discount so be prepared for a dry cardboard like pizza they have lost my business and future referrals.
