First time trying One Pie Pizza.. && I guarantee it will NOT be the last. The 2 Large Slice Special is totally worth the price. Each slice is huge, generously loaded with toppings, & I am SUPER HAPPY that I picked this spot! Full to capacity!
T
Travis K
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Liked
• 5/17/26
• DoorDash order
OMG! Amazing 1/2 Breakfast Pizza! Perfect proportions of topping and ratio of eggs, cheese meat sauce and crust. topping and cheese go right to the edges like a perfect pan style. Fresh, hot and delicious. I'm not sure why I have waited this long between visit to One Pie Pizza. Definitely going back soon! Best Breakfast Pizza in the entire area. I challenge you to find something better.
M
Michael D
6 contributions
Loved
• 1/12/26
• DoorDash order
My favorite pizzeria in all of WNY. Their homemade blue cheese is delicious and goes incredibly well with their pizza. They're one of the few places, and best places, in WNY that does Gluten-Free Pizza right. I never dip my pizza into blue cheese but One Pie makes it go so well together. Highly recommend ordering from here.
A
Amy H
315 contributions
Loved
• 8/31/25
• DoorDash order
First time ordering and really impressed! Fresh slices made to order, ice cold soda and free homemade (?) blue cheese ! PACKED with toppings, great sauce and dough. Rivals Picassos for crust thickness/type but better lol ... 2 Large Slice Special
M
Michael D
6 contributions
Loved
• 1/1/26
• DoorDash order
One Pie is one of the best pizzerias in Buffalo! It is especially good with their homemade blue cheese, which is out of this world, honestly. I never have pizza with blue cheese but this is the only pizzeria that makes it worthwhile. It's delicious! I pay an extra $3 just to have it delivered from West Seneca. Just be mindful of you're allegeric to Yellow 5 don't order the banana peppers.
