Everything I have ever ordered from Papa Allen's is excellent. I love their Garden Salad. It's really large and always crisp and fresh, with a large selection of dressings to choose from. This was my first time ordering the Seafood Hoagie and it was really delicious. The warm shrimp and crab brushed with garlic butter was wonderful topped with tomatoes, red onion and lettuce. So moist and flavorful! Their food is a consistently excellent.
C
Colleen D
24 contributions
Liked
• 9/25/23
• DoorDash order
the pizza has delicious cheese /sauce / toppings. I did not like that the crust was soggy, it will taste way better tomorrow when I crisp it in the oven
the beef ravioli...amazing!! loved it, delicious sauce and cheese
the wings were gross, soggy..once again will taste better tomorrow when I crisp them up in the oven
the Tiramisu ..frozen!! and so tiny! absolutely not worth the money
B
Brian L
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/21/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered the breaded zucchini and it must have weighed two pounds from all the grease engorged in each zucchini plank. I literally could not eat any of them and the side salad was half brown and slimed. No reorders from me for sure
R
Robert K
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/14/25
• DoorDash order
Ordered two small variants of the pizza assuming they must be bigger for being $18 for a pepperoni one. I was shocked to see how small and uncooked our two pizzas were, especially at paying $18 a piece. Three little ceasars pizzas worth and the quality isn't much better.
C
Chelsea L
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/24/24
• DoorDash order
This pizza used to be a 10/10... hadn't ordered it in a while and its changed for the worse. I paid way too much money for an overcooked piece of cardboard, 1/4 tsp of sauce, and rubber cheese on top. They even reduced the size of their side sauces by half. Waste of money. Might as well order a chain pizza for $6 at this quality.
