i ordered the Create Your Own Pizza buy 1 get 1 free deal. the taste of the pizza is amazing, like, really really good. cheese is on point, sauce has great flavor, stuffed crust is also good. the only issue I have is with the toppings. I had beef and onions which were $2.20 each. I'm sorry but I did NOT get 2 and a half dollars worth of toppings, easy like 10 cents MAX. if I could rate my experience with this order it would be like a 4.3. overall delicious pizza, but come on Papa John's, toppings are easily the thing you guys get most ROI on per pizza. why not over deliver with the toppings, add a little more than what your customers are expecting, not less. would order again without the toppings.
J
Jeanna E
2 contributions
Loved
• 5/30/25
• DoorDash order
You can never go wrong with Papa's Pizza.
It always tastes so fresh.
The chicken Alfredo was full of vegetables. Really nice. Pull apart, cinnamon dessert, it's so moist, melts in your mouth.
H
Helen B
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/23/25
• DoorDash order
Greasy, cheese slides off when picking up a slice. Poorly cut. Too much sauce. Not worth the cost
