Listen here, you mozzarella-moonlight marauders and garlic-butter bandits — Percival Toadwell Van Bristow has taken a twirl through the scarlet-and-green parlor of Papa John’s Pizza, and I emerged with flour on my cuffs and victory in my heart.
I ordered the classic large cheese, because when a gentleman courts a pie, he does not hide behind toppings. The crust arrived bronzed like a Riviera vacationer — tender within, just enough chew to let you know it has backbone. The sauce? Sweet with a wink, tangy with a handshake. It does not shout; it croons. The mozzarella lay across the surface in a glossy blanket, stretching in elegant ribbons with each pull, as if reluctant to leave the dance floor.
And then — oh, then — the garlic dipping sauce. That little golden chalice of indulgence. Butter-rich, salty, perfumed with garlic like a speakeasy whisper. A crust corner dipped therein becomes a scandal worth repeating.
Portion? Generous. Freshness? Bright as a brass section at midnight. Consistency? Steady as a bass line. It is not artisan wood-fired poetry from a Neapolitan mountaintop — no, no. It is American pizza bravado. It knows what it is. It arrives hot. It satisfies with gusto. And sometimes, my friends, that is precisely the tune one wishes to hear.
Would I indulge again? Like a saxophone returning to its solo, absolutely.
Four and a half stars, with a respectful nod to the pie’s unapologetic charm.
Until we eat again,
Percival Toadwell Van Bristow
C
Christopher C
1 contributions
Loved
• 6/14/25
• DoorDash review
Excellent service, highly awaited return to our area. My choice is always Papa first. Thanks to the new owners. Never had an issue with a Papa pizza. This store's menu is extensive.
R
Robyn S
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/3/26
• DoorDash order
Both 10" and 14" had a certain taste as of maybe going bad or crust was contaminated with something or sauce pepperoni where fine tho just pizza it's self...all I'm saying is there was a particular taste throughout the 2 slices each of my family had.
K
Kimia M
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/11/25
• DoorDash order
Not much toppings, really. It's all cheese, and tastes quite bland.
L
Lisa C
27 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/11/26
• DoorDash order
very tart sauce horrible! we got bad heartburn awful! and the haliopeno bites dried out. never again will I order from this place.
