Really good pizza from a family owned/operated Papa Johns, probably the best in town when compared to the other big name competitors.
The Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza was made with care and I'd order from here again.
A
Ashlee-Rose Y
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/23/23
• DoorDash order
Very dry, very mini icing. Ordered an extra icing and got maybe half an oz for $1.25. Taste not bad, kind of plain, just so dry.
Chicken was rubbery, again not much flavour and kinda dry. Ordered extra marinara and only got one. Again, tiny container but more like an oz for $1.25.
F
Fred H
Local Expert • 119 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/22/23
• DoorDash order
The wings are amazing, but I was fully underwhelmed by the absence of toppings! 5 meats, onions, hot peppers, and two extra selections of cheese, and it was thinner than my phone... Really disapointed since I barely eat pizza anymore. Normally, I eat 2 pieces and 4 wings, freeze the rest... I needed to eat 3 pieces to feel sated.
J
Jasmine W
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/24/23
• DoorDash review
FYI they put pepperoni on their donair pizza. I guess I should have read the description, but I've had donair pizzas from every other place and no pepperoni. Grease also soaked through both boxes which I've never seen before, and I only live a few blocks away. if you were thinking papa johns is a safe bet because youve had it in another city - think again it's so pricy for quality worse than little Cesar's lol I paid 39.00 for one pizza bread and a pepsi
miss s
8 contributions
Liked
• 7/1/25
• DoorDash review
tasty food, on par prices pretty much as enjoyble as then other chain pizza joints.
you want quality, filling, and flavor town local pizza? go to Islanders!!!! best in town!
