Experience the authentic taste of New York-style pizza and traditional Italian cuisine with an American twist. At Papi NYC , we're passionate about serving top-notch dishes that blend heritage and inn…
For this being a cheese slice, i must say it is 100 times better than joes pizza. 10/10 would definitely recommend from the choice in music, to the friendly staff, amazing smell, great tasting slice, the entire experience was beyond my expectation for visiting a pizza store. :)
J
Joe G
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/8/26
• DoorDash order
The GF lasagna is fantastic and so is the GF Bolognese pasta, but the GF Bolognese is maybe one of the worst values I've had in a long time on this app. It costs $25 for barely a cup of penne pasta. I couldn't believe the size of the portion. Hardly enough to count as a meal. It would barely be considered a side order. I'm only leaving the review so they will hopefully change the portion size. The lasagna was plenty but the GF penne portion size was so disappointing that idk if I'd ever order again.
G
Gian D
4 contributions
Loved
• 2/3/26
• DoorDash order
Absolutely outstanding spicy vodka rigatoni. The portion size was very abundant, the pasta perfectly cooked al dente, and beautifully seared for extra flavor. Rich, creamy, with just the right kick. The pizza was just as impressive—crunchy, light, and topped with super fresh burrata that melted perfectly into every bite. You can really taste the quality and care in every dish. Definitely ordering again!
D
DQ M
1 contributions
Loved
• 6/16/26
• DoorDash order
I had the Norma Pinsa and a Mexican Coke to wash it down, something quick for late lunch. I was thinking it was going to be an overly breaded and oily slice of eggplant on top of a dry pizza crust, but it definitely was not. The delivery was on time which meant it was still warm and crispy and soft where it needed to be. You could taste the freshness of the eggplant and cherry tomatoes in every bite. PAPI hasn't let me down yet.
D
Dennis M
1 contributions
Loved
• 3/7/26
• DoorDash order
Ordered the Spicy Vodka and Norma pastas. I really only get pizza from PAPI but decided to try their pasta - and I will definitely order again. The portions for both were certainly a good size but not too much where you're stuffed and can't move for at least an hour. The delivery was pretty quickly so I was able to taste the freshness of the pastas themselves. Looking forward to ordering pasta again!
